|“You Set One Foot on This Porch and I’ll Shoot You Like a Dog”
[no title entered in day books]
|Alternate Titles:||A Daughter of the South |
|Size:||36″H x 24″W|
|Published:|| Stanley, Caroline Abbot. “A Daughter of the South.” The Century Illustrated Monthly Magazine, April 1910: 820.
caption: ‘You set one foot on this porch and I’ll shoot you like a dog.’
|Inscription:||ll: Frank E. Schoonover / ’09|
|Comments:||TP 3/28/02; form 11/4/02; index; edit; relined|
|Commentary:|| After considering the first image sent by Schoonover, the Editorial Editor, R.U. Johnson of The Century Illustrated Monthly Magazine, wrote this letter on April 15, 1909, asking for a change:
“Mr. Gilder and I feel that while this picture of Mr. Schoonover’s is a striking one, the woman’s face and figure do not indicate the type of Southern lady which is expected in the stories of old Southern families. The story of her feminine gentleness and kindness make an effective contrast to the determination displayed in this scene. Mr. Schoonover has well expressed the determination – almost too well. Can she not be made less hard, more lovable to look upon, with more Southern high lady style of the kind that goes with the pillars – perhaps with war-time curls? We are sure Mr. Schoonover can make something very fetching.” (archives, correspondence)
Upon receipt of the letter and the painting, the artist re-drew parts of the figure of the woman and added some curls around her face. The enhanced painting was published as a half tone plate engraved by R. Barley.
|Provenance:||Collection of Mrs. L.G. Hagner; Clubhouse Art Gallery, Media, Pennsylvania ; private collection; descended in the family to private collection|